by Diane Montagna

Pope Leo XIV has said that he has no immediate plans to rescind Traditionis Custodes, the 2021 motu proprio restricting the traditional Roman liturgy, but that dispensations are available to allow for the celebration of Mass in the old rite.

The Pope's comments came during an inflight press conference on his return from Lima to Rome, following his 12-day apostolic visit to South America.

Asked by French journalist Jean-Marie Guénois if he is "considering making Traditionis Custodes more flexible," the Pope said:

"No, not right now. Traditionis Custodes is the decision of Pope Francis, and we will continue to follow that. Traditionis Custodes includes possibilities of dispensation or of allowing the Tridentine Mass — or the Vetus OrdoMass — to be celebrated. And so, again, for the unity of the Church, the vast majority of Catholics around the world, we celebrate the rite of Vatican II, of Paul VI, and we will continue to do that. And there is an avenue available for those who wish to apply for the dispensation." (Video here: timestamp 42:25)

The remarks appear to confirm, at least in part, the recent claim by Cardinal Arthur Roche, Prefect of the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, that the Pope "is not going to change Traditionis Custodes. He is not going to go back to Summorum Pontificum."

Unity or Uniformity

Earlier in the press conference, Pope Leo had appealed to Church unity when he said he had no plans to allow the ordination of married men as priests. But his decision to keep Traditionis Custodes in place for the same reason implies that he considers unity in the Latin Church as requiring liturgical uniformity — something liturgical scholars have argued is foreign to the history of the Roman Rite.

Furthermore, his implied emphasis on liturgical conformity contradicts his own remarks before taking questions from reporters. Reflecting on his apostolic visit to South America, he suggested that it could aptly be titled Magnifica Humanitas, "because it was a true experience of meeting people and recognizing the gifts" of different cultures. "We saw it in so many different ways, so many different colors, different music, different expressions of faith and devotion," he said.

Dispensations

On the issue Pope Leo raised about the possibility of dispensations, it's worth noting what prompted the need for bishops to obtain a dispensation from the Dicastery for Divine Worship.

Because diocesan bishops were using their legitimate power according to canon law (Canon 87 §1) to dispense from the provisions of Traditionis Custodes, Cardinal Roche found it necessary in February 2022 to obtain a rescript from Pope Francis to "ensure the correct application" of the motu proprio.

Henceforth, a bishop who wished to use Canon 87 §1 to dispense from Traditionis Custodes had to inform the Dicastery for Divine Worship, which would then decide either to affirm or overrule his decision. The rescript thus severely limited the freedom of bishops as "directors, promoters, and guardians of the entire liturgical life" in their dioceses (Canon 835 §1; cf. Christus Dominus, n. 15).

The rescript met with criticism from canonists who argued that Cardinal Roche had overstepped the mark and claimed a jurisdiction the Dicastery can't have, because he was trying to control something that lies in the competency of the diocesan bishop.

Should he wish to, the Pope could revoke the rescript without rescinding Traditionis Custodes, thus restoring to local bishops the power to dispense from its provisions for the spiritual good of their dioceses. In the meantime, it remains to be seen whether, in light of Pope Leo’s remarks, more bishops will seek a dispensation from the Dicastery for Divine Worship and whether Cardinal Roche will be more generous in granting them.